What were some of your favourite theories from the earlier seasons, (The Boys: S1/S2)? - Reddit
reddit.com
This Reddit thread revisits early fan theories about Homelander's psychology — and reveals how unchecked power and performative loyalty make his violence feel inevitable, not shocking.
Authoritarian Personality TheoryPerformative PowerNarcissistic CollapseSocial Learning Theory
Theory Briefing
- Fans theorized Homelander would actually massacre protesters, predicting his S4 fantasy would become reality long before the show confirmed it.
- The thread highlights how audiences instinctively applied authoritarian psychology to Homelander, sensing that performative control always breaks into open violence.
- Early theories proved surprisingly accurate, suggesting viewers were reading real-world power-collapse patterns into the superhero satire from the very start.