Subscribe: Subscribe by Email RSS Follow us on Twitter Login | Register |

US Supreme Court: Judicial theories

 
US supreme court
Library of Congress
The expected retirement of Justice John Paul Stevens and subsequent supreme court nomination fight will cast a bright light on judicial theories of interpretation. Get them here.
Agree 100% / Disagree 0%

It is widely-expected that the US Supreme Court will see another vacancy in 2010 when Justice John Paul Stevens retires after 35 years of service. That means a nomination battle. 2010 is also an election year in which the Republican party can expect to gain seats in both house of Congress.  The coming nomination battle will be even more intense than Sotomayer's.   

Republicans don't have the numbers to actually block a nominee, but they do see the political opportunities in fighting the battle.

Said Sen. John Thune (R-SD): "If it's 2010, that's an election year and it's an issue that really energizes the Republican base."

Should Stevens retire and a nomination battle occur, expect to hear much about existing theories of judicial interpretation shaping the court.

Selected Theories

Image of US Supreme Court building.

John Roberts' Judicial Restraint Theory 75%

John Roberts' theory of judicial restraint is changing, and limiting the supreme court.
Justice Antonin Scalia

Constitutional Originalism Theory 67%

The first major biography of Justice Antonin Scalia was released this week. In it, legal reporter Joan Biskupic offers a detailed account of the life and theory of Scalia, the standard bearer of the judicial theory of constitutional originalism.
Hartford firefighters with their lawyer after the Supreme Court ruled they were discriminated against because they are white.

The Ricci Case and Sonia Sotomayer 100%

In Ricci vs. Stefano, the Supreme Court whacks Sonia Sotomayer's 'judicial minimalism' theory by overruling her earlier decision.

Leave a Comment

Login, or fill in the required fields below.





Allowed tags: <b> <i> <p> <br> <a> <ol> <ul> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <em> <strong> <tt> <blockquote> <div>

Submit Submit