The famous philosopher John Locke argued that a child's mind
is a 'blank slate' which can be written on and molded
whichever way society want it to be. Christian doctrine says that
babies are born selfish and must go through a spiritual rebirth
where all the evil we are born with is washed from our souls.
Philosopher Jean-Jacques Rousseau said that humans are born with an
innate goodness and that we susceptible to being spoiled by the
evils that exist in the world around us. Though there have been
many proposals throughout the ages, everyone has been able to agree
on the fact that our minds undergo rapid growth and change as we
morph from children to adults. Since philosophy and religion, the
field of
psychology
has been interested in "the scientific study of age-related
changes in behavior, thinking, emotions, and personality,"
[1]
which is called human development.
Nature vs. Nurture
When discussing human development, a good thing to keep in mind
is the classic debate of nature vs. nurture. On one side of the
debate we have people arguing that we are born with our personality
traits and that our psyche is shaped by purely by internal
biological factors like deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA). On the other
side there are people arguing that our personalities our molded
purely by external factors such as family, friends, teachers, and
society as a whole. The general modern scientific consensus on the
debate is that our personalities are not shaped entirely by one or
the other but rather by a mix of both biological and environmental
factors. Most modern day psychologists disregard the debate as
being outdated.
[2]
Most professionals acknowledge that we are born with a temperament
that will follow us our throughout our lives. Just because someone
is born with an aggressive/fussy temperament does not mean that
they will grow up to commit acts of violence, though it helps. At
the same time, someone with a docile temperament might be capable
of murder. What is certain is that our heredity and DNA can carry
traits which make us susceptible to mental disorders and
psychopathology, which can have serious affects on personality.
[3]
Development Domains
Scientists studying human development divide factors of growth into three different categories called the domains of development.
- The physiological processes and changes that occur in the human body such as puberty.
- Changes to the way we think, our intelligence, memory capabilities, etc.
- Changes that occur between an individual and other people, including development of social skills, high self esteem.
The domains often overlap as people go through developmental
changes. For instance, the onset of clinical depression not only
changes the way someone thinks but can also disturb their social
lives and lead to physiological changes such as weight gain or
loss.
Changes
As a child gets older they may go from having zero friends to having ten, or from 3 foot 2 inches to 6 foot 3 inches. These changes in numbers are classified as quantitative change. This is sometimes referred to as continuity.
- If a child goes from enjoying Pokemon card collecting to football card collecting it is change in kind or type, which makes it a qualitative change. Changes in likes, dislikes, and actions are sometimes called discontinuity.
- Each culture has a series of changes they expect every human to go through as they age. This sequence of changes and experiences is called the social clock.
- When a human is sensitive to the presence or absence of some kind of experience, such as not being able to go to their high school prom.
- If a person changes in unexpected ways that are not typical and it is ultimately harmful to the individual then they have experiences atypical development.
Research
To support their theories or hypotheses, Psychologists will do
research and perform tests to obtain empirical evidence that either
backs up or discredits their claims. When dealing with human
development, these methods are often used for age-related studies.
There are three commonly used research method designs.
Cross-sectional Design - When groups of people of
different age are compared to one another, a cross-sectional design
is used. This is helpful when trying to see how something changes
in individuals during different stages of their lives. For
instance, a cross-sectional designed study might take three people
in their 20's, three in their 30's, and three in their
40's. Then they test their memory capabilities to decide
whether or not memory declines as we age.
Longitudinal Designs - The problem with
cross-sectional design is that it takes random individuals and
studies them for only a short period of time, which does not really
show how each individual changes as they age. With longitudinal
designs, the same people will be studied over a long period of
time. This helps find errors in the study. For instance, a person
might show good memory when they are 20 years old and still have
just as good a memory when they are 60. Since their memory did not
decline it might mean the hypothesis is flawed.
Sequential Designs - Longitudinal designs have
their problems too. They involve getting the same people over and
over again to take the same tests or do the same things. People
might learn how to perfect their scores on these tests and others
might decide they don't want to help with the study anymore.
Sequential designs mix aspects of cross-sectional and longitudinal
designs to try and reduce the errors that occur in such studies.
People are studied over time but cohorts are used. A cohort is
someone who has experienced the same things as someone else and are
the same age. This helps to show whether or not results are
consistent in everyone.
When a psychologist does a very detailed examination of one
individual it is called a case study. This is helpful when trying
to determine why or how someone is experiencing a stage or aspect
of life. Humans are very complicated and individualistic creatures
and case studies help to hone in on one individual's uniqueness
and solve their specific problems or shed insight on humans the way
large scale studies cannot.
[4]
During the course of a case study, a psychologist might use
naturalistic observation, which is the process of studying
people in their normal environment. This can offer much more
insight into the way humans think and are affected by society. It
can also lead to better data since the subject does not feel
awkward or out of place due to a fabricated environment.
Psychoanalytic Theories The most famous psychologist of all
time, Sigmund Freud, was the founder of psychoanalysis and
psychoanalytic theories.
[5]
These theories are based on the belief that developmental changes
occur because of the influence of internal drives and emotions on
behavior.
Freud's Psychosexual Theory
From Freud's psychoanalysis theories
psychologists were given one possible insight as to how the
conscious and unconscious mind work.
[6]
Freud believed that there is a constant unconscious drive in humans
to seek pleasure, which he called the
libido. He argued that the human personality can be
divided into three different parts.
- Part of the unconscious, the id houses the libido. It is the instinct all humans are born with that gives us carnal, animal like desire. It causes us to pursue sex and be aggressive.
The ego develops in our first 2 to 3 years of life and is the conscious, thinking part of our minds. The ego is the part of our personalities we are most aware of. Part of the ego's job is to help satisfy the needs of the id. It's job is to keep all three components of personality in harmony.
The superego is the root of our morality. The rules we are taught by family, friends, and society all merge and become part of the superego. The superego helps us decide between right and wrong. The ego's job is to try and satisfy the id without going against rules set forth by the superego.
When these components are in conflict with one another it
creates tension and emotional problems. To get rid of this tension
a person might use
defense mechanisms which are ways of thinking about a
situation to reduce anxiety. Examples of defense mechanisms include
repression, denial, or projection.
[7]
Without defense mechanisms, Freud believed that the person with
conflicting personality components would be under so much stress
that they develop mental illness or kill themselves.
While Freud was first psychoanalyzing his patients he noticed a
trend. Almost all of them had memories of sexual feelings and
behaviors from their childhood. As a result, Freud developed a
series of stages that he believed everyone went through. These
stages all had to do with sexual development. If a child was not
given an upbringing which successfully carried them through these
stages then they would develop a
fixation. They become study at a certain stage, which
results in the person acting in ways that show unresolved problems
and unmet needs.
The Oedipus complex is a collection of the feelings a young
boy has during their phallic stage. According to Freud, boys this
age are supposed to have very strong feelings for their mother and
because of those feelings they develop a jealousy toward their
father. Sometimes the feelings are so strong that they want to kill
their father. Girls will have a similar experience called the
elektra complex, where their attraction to their father will result
in feelings of distaste for their mothers.
Erikson's Psychosocial Stages
Erik Erikson was a psychologist who had an alternative
opinion to Freud's about human development. Erikson proposed a
theory composed of various stages but rather than focusing on sex
he focused on social changes. His theory states that we go through
eight stages and that in each one we face a conflict that can
either be successfully or unsuccessfully resolved.
The positive characteristics shown in the diagram will only
be gained if the dilemma in the stage is successfully resolved. In
the case of trust vs. mistrust, the dilemma should be resolved so
that the person has trust rather than mistrust.
Freud's psychosexual theory has some shortcomings in
that sexual feelings are probably not as important to development
as Freud believed. Erikson's psychosocial theory has some
shortcomings in that it is very simplified.
Learning Theories Whereas psychoanalytic focus on internal
drives and emotions, learning theories propose that through
external factors, especially the environment, people can be trained
and learn to do or be anything. John Watson, the psychologist who
first developed learning theories , called this
behavioralism.
[1]
Behavioralism defines development in terms of behavior changes
caused by environment influences.
Learning theories say that development should happen
through the accumulation experiences.
Pavlov's Classical Conditioning
Ivan Pavlov found that humans can acquire new
signals for existing behaviors. This means that we learn through
stimuli. We come to expect certain stimulating effects from certain
things. He saw that when we know something should happen when we
develop a
conditioned response.
[8]
Skinner's Operant Conditioning
B.F. Skinner proposed operant conditioning, which says that
people can learn to repeat or stop behaviors because of the
consequences that go along with them.
Reinforcement is anything that follows a behavior and
causes it to be repeated. This can be as simple as giving out a
piece of candy every time the subject has successfully done
something. Positive reinforcement would be something pleasant which
causes the subject to repeat the behavior over again. It reinforces
the action and causes them to do it again in hopes of recieving
candy.
Punishment is anything that follows a behavior and causes
it to stop. Also called negative reinforcement or nonreinforcement,
this might involve taking an insulin shot to prevent the negative
effects of diabetes. The shot isn't pleasant but most be done
to prevent a less pleasant occurence.
Extinction occurs when a behavior is completely eliminated
through nonreinforcement.
Shaping is the learning of complex behavior through the
reinforcement of intermediate steps. An example of this would be
learning to play a sport. You learn one step at a time, reinforcing
yourself alont the way, until you can finally bring all of the
steps together to successfully play the sport.
Bandura's Social-Learning Theory
Albert Bandura was a psychologist who had the idea that
learning does not necessarilty require reinforcement. He believed
that we can also learn by observing other people. Children learn
how to behave by looking at their siblings and other adults.
Bandura believes that this kind of learning depends on four
things.
What the person pays attention to
What they are able to remember
What they are physicially able to copy
What they are motivated to imitate.
Bandura also believed that we learn from not only behavior but
also ideas, expectations, internal standards, and self-concepts.
Bandura calls this
self-efficacy which can influence our well-being and
physical health as well as learning.
[9]
Cognitive Theories When theories emphasize mental aspects of
development such as memory and logic then they are categorized as
cognitive theories. These theories look at the human mind as the
focal point and base everything around that.
Piaget's Cognitive Developmental Theory
Jean Piaget developed a very famous theory about
human development. There are a number of terms that accompaned
Piaget's influential theory.
- An internal cognitive structure that provides an individual with a procedure to use in a specific circumstance.
- When we use scemes to make sense of experiences it is called assimilation.
- Schemes are sometimes changed as a result of some new information acquired through assimilation.
The process of balancing assimilation and accomodation to create schemas that fit the environment someone is in.
Piaget divided his theory into stages:
Information-processing Theory - A theoretical
model that uses the computer as a model to explain how the mind
manages information. Often this model will show how humans receive
incoming sensory data which is stored in sensory memory, then sent
to short term memory which can then be sent into long-term memory.
[10]
Since Piaget's theory there has been the development of
neo-Piagetian theory
. Neo-Piagetian theories often use
information-processing principles to explain the development stages
in Piaget's theory.
Biological Theories Theories that combine physiological and
biological aspects of development are called biological theories.
Some can address groups of people and others focus on
individuals.There are certain beliefs that biological theories will
follow or exhibit, although they are not required.
- There is a belief that human beings have genetic traits that will be exhibited in all members of the species. This is called nativism, and is used to explain how people are programmed to be a certain way by their genetic code which the environment has no influence on.
- Ethologists believe that survival behaviors evolved through natural selection. Behaviors and skills that are successful will be passed on to the next generation. Those that do not have these necessary skills will die and not pass on their genes. Ethologists also believe that emotional relationships are required for the survival of human infants. For instance, if a mother didn't emotionally respond the the cries of her child then she would have no desire to take care of that child.
- The study of society using the methods and concepts of biology is called sociobiology. Genes that help groups of people survive are often the core interest of sociobiologists. Sociobiology tries to find the common links in all of human society, or the universal rules that all humans seem biologically programmed to create. Evolution selects the genes that will best promote the survival of the human species .
- Studying how heredity affects individual differences among humans is called behavior genetics. Heredity has been show to affect such things as intelligence, aggressiveness, and shyness. Behavior geneticists have studied identical twins to see what characteristics are present in both because they have the same DNA.
Vgotsky's Sociocultural Theory Piaget believed that complex
thinking were developed through a child's explorations. Vgotsky
proposed that complex thinking develops through social
interactions.
[11]
When a child's learning experience is guided by an adult it is
called
scaffolding. For successful scaffolding an adult must
model the best strategy, gain and keep the child's attention,
and adapt the learning to the child's developmental level,
which Vgotsky called the
zone of proximal development.
Bronfenbrenner's Ecological Theory Who we are and the
actions we make are not defined solely by our inner cognitive
mechanism, but are decided in large by exterior environment. Such
is the theory presented by scholar Urie Bronfenbrenner in his
Ecological Systems Theory. Though Bronfenbrenner has passed away,
his work is still widely admired today and was undoubtedly a leader
in the field of developmental psychology. His Ecological Systems
Theory was first published in 1979. In this theory, Bronfenbrenner
presents the concept that there are four environmental systems
interlinked bi-directionally that each play a specific role in the
development of humans throughout their lifespan. These systems are
the microsystem, the exosystem, and the macrosystem.
[12]
Diagram Courtesy of
http://reginaldwilliams.blogspot.com/2007_04_24_archive.html
Eclecticism A modern trend in human developmental studies is
the use of many theories and perspectives to explain and study
development. This is called eclecticism and it is helpful because
psychologists are no longer restricted to the rigid confines of
just one theory anymore. If something isn't accounted for in
one theory, then the psychologist can take it from another theory
to help with his or her studies. In a sense the theories are molded
to represent a more realistic view of human kind.
Theories Compared All of the theories discussed so far have
their own merit and usefulness. A developmentalist would look at
all of these theories and apply the one which fits their current
purposes best. To do this, it is helpful to compare all of the
theories at once:
[1]
Conclusion None of these theories are completely correct and
none of them are incorrect. They are proposals that shed light on
the development of human beings. Psychologists will always argue
over which theories are superior to others but the most important
thing to keep in mind it doesn't matter. If a theory helps you
do your work then it has served its purpose. If you disagree with
any of the theories then you can modify them or create your own.
Human development is a very interesting and important focus of
study and its theories will continue to be useful for anyone
interested in the biological and psychological sciences.
References
Boyd, D., & Bee, H. (2005). Lifespan Development. Boston: Pearson/A and B.
Ridley, M. (2003) Nature Via Nurture: Genes, Experience, and What Makes us Human. Harper Collins.
Mental Illness Exacts Heavy Toll, Beginning in Youth. DNA
Paternity Testing, Sibling and Immigration Tests.
http://www.dna-testing-paternity.com/content/7676/mental-illness-exacts-heavy-toll-beginni.php
Case Studies. Writing@CSU Home Page
http://writing.colostate.edu/guides/research/casestudy/
The Conscious and Unconscious Mind. About.com.
http://psychology.about.com/od/theoriesofpersonality/a/consciousuncon.htm
FREUD's Theory of Psychosexual Development.
a2zpsychology.com
http://www.a2zpsychology.com/great_psychologists/freud_psychosexual_thoery.htm
Section 6: Freud's Ego Defense Mechanisms. AllPsych
Online.
http://allpsych.com/psychology101/defenses.html
Classical Conditioning. Ivan Pavlov
http://www.mucknmire.com/wam101/pavlov.html
Social Learning Theory. Ormrod, J.E. (1999). Human
learning (3rd ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
http://teachnet.edb.utexas.edu/~lynda_abbott/Social.html
Theories Used in Research Information Processing Theory
(2005). Appalachian State University
http://www.istheory.yorku.ca/informationprocessingtheory.htm
Vygotsky & Socio-Cultural Theory. KidsDevelopment
http://www.kidsdevelopment.co.uk/VygotskySocioCulturalTheory.html
Bronfenbrenner, U. (1979). The ecology of human development. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.